The faith-centered Saint Clare Collective in Bearden breathes new life into an 1880s chapel
By Bee Goodman
The original bell from the 1876 church still hangs and rings in Knoxville’s newest Catholic gift store: Saint Clare Collective. It hung in a church that survived over a century of Sunday services and a string of tenants that included a countertop store, a yoga class, and, most recently, a Brazilian jiu-jitsu studio. Today it belongs to Saint Clare Collective, a new faith-centered gift store at 5902 Kingston Pike in Bearden. Its founder says her children love to ring it.
“The original bell is from 1876, and you can still ring it today,” said owner Allie Fleming, who opened the store in the restored chapel next to Pelican’s SnoBalls. “My kids love to ring it.”

The original bell from the 1880s chapel still hangs and rings in the renewed home of Saint Clare Collective. (Photo Bee Goodman)
The store celebrated its grand opening on All Saints Day, Sunday, Nov. 1. It has also been blessed by Father Danny Herman of the Cathedral of the Most Sacred Heart of Jesus Parish, a fitting start for a building that spent its first decades as a house of worship.
For Mrs. Fleming, a mother of four and a longtime Sacred Heart parishioner, the shop is the result of a spring spent reconsidering her life, followed by a summer in which, she says, nearly everything fell into place.
A calling, then 100 days
Mrs. Fleming spent more than 15 years in corporate America. In May, she decided to step back to focus on her family, her children, and herself. During that time, she said, she prayed and reflected on what to do next. The idea of a Catholic gift shop had long been in the back of her mind.
“I felt this true calling that was pulling me to do it,” she said. “It was something I thought we needed. I knew my friends needed it.”
What followed was a sprint. From the decision to launch to opening day, Mrs. Fleming says, about 100 days passed. In that time, she found a space, cleaned and renovated it, selected inventory, and opened the doors. Retail openings, especially ones that involve a century-old building, commonly take a year or more.
Early on, she said, the logistics were handled in her own home. The inventory was sorted and staged in her dining room and garage.
Mrs. Fleming said the speed convinced her she was on the right path. She and her husband, Jimmy, told friends over dinner how they had found the perfect space and that it happened to become available. Their friends’ reaction stuck with her.
“They were like, ‘That’s not a coincidence. That’s the Holy Spirit working through you guys,’” Mrs. Fleming said. “Ever since then, it has just all so seamlessly fallen into place over those 100 days that it couldn’t be anything else.”
A building with a long memory
The building was not on the market when the Flemings first saw it. Their Realtor knew the owner, who agreed to let them look inside.

Owner Allie Fleming is a proud wife and mother of four: daughter Grace, 10, and sons (from left) Joseph Patrick, 4; Sully, 6; and James 8, pictured with husband Jimmy Fleming. All have shared the excitement of the opening of Saint Clare Collective.
The chapel, in Mrs. Fleming’s description, was in rough shape. There was no electricity. The space smelled, her husband said, “like a wrestling-room, a sweaty locker room.” Blue mats had been bolted to the walls of the sanctuary, where students of the former studio had trained. The basement was damp and musty. The refrigerator was full of rotten food, and there was trash throughout.
“We really cleaned this entire place up,” Mrs. Fleming said.
Cleaning was the first job before making any plans for shelves or displays.
Beneath the grime, she said, was a building with what she calls “good bones”: beautiful wood, a handsome door, and the proportions of a real chapel. Left behind in the mess was also an original church pew that now greets customers as they enter the gift shop.
The site’s history reaches back well into the 19th century. According to Mrs. Fleming, the original church, which she describes as the first Christian church in the Bearden area, started in 1876 in a building that stood to the right of the current structure. That building burned. The white chapel that stands today was built in 1924. The congregation drew worshipers from around the Knoxville area, and the building served as a Korean Christian church until 2002.
After that, it changed hands and uses repeatedly. It was at various points a countertop store, a place where Mrs. Fleming’s own friends claimed to once practice yoga, and a Maker’s Mark location, before becoming the jiu-jitsu studio that was its most recent occupant.
At one point, the chapel nearly disappeared altogether. Mrs. Fleming said it was purchased with the intention of demolishing it, along with the neighboring blue snow-cone house, to make way for a Taco Bell. Attempts to sell the white building to someone who could move it off the property were difficult and costly, she said. The plan was abandoned when the developers found they could not fit in a drive-thru, in part because of the historic cemetery behind the property, where several prominent local families were buried beginning in the 1800s.
Saving what could be saved
The restoration was a family and community effort. Mrs. Fleming, her husband, their four children, and a number of relatives and friends worked on the building, and repurposing original pieces became a guiding principle.
The most demanding project involved the bookshelves. In the parish office on the other half of the building, which Mrs. Fleming does not lease, were built-in wooden bookcases that were about to be torn out and thrown away. She asked if she could take them.
“Each one of those is so unique and challenging because they’re all different sizes,” she said. “To take them apart and put them all back together up here, it wasn’t like this was the exact layout down there.”
The reconstructed bookcases now hold merchandise in the shop. An original church pew has also found a home inside, along with the historic bell.
“It’s been challenging,” Mrs. Fleming said, “but it’s been so rewarding at the same time.”
Neighbors at the front doors
As work progressed, neighbors began stopping by. According to Mrs. Fleming, a couple buying snow cones next door heard activity in the chapel and came over to look. The woman had been baptized in the building.
“She was so excited to see that we were bringing it back to life,” Mrs. Fleming said.

The newly opened store welcomed many shoppers to take in its variety of Catholic gifts on opening day Nov. 1, All Saints Day. (Photo Bee Goodman)
The visitor contacted her mother, a member of one of the church’s founding families whose father helped build part of the chapel. The mother later visited the building herself. Members of Friends of Cavett Station, a nonprofit that preserves Mars Hill Cemetery at Historic Cavett Station, also volunteered their time and effort during early stages of the project. The Bearden Historical Society has since become involved, Mrs. Fleming said, and is working to tell the chapel’s story and to help preserve the cemetery behind it.
Terry Faulkner, a Friends of Cavett Station board member, said the group was glad to see the chapel’s details preserved.
“For many years, this chapel was a place where congregants gathered and built community,” Mrs. Faulkner said. “Too many historic buildings and traditions are torn down and erased. Saint Clare Collective is a lovely next chapter in the legacy of this historic Bearden chapel.”
Why Saint Clare
The shop’s name comes from two places. Saint Clare of Assisi, the follower of Saint Francis who founded the Poor Clares, has long been a saint Mrs. Fleming looks up to because of her devotion to her faith. The name also honors the St. Clare Guild, the women’s guild at Sacred Heart that Mrs. Fleming joined after moving back to Knoxville while pregnant with her first child.
The guild gave her what she describes as a sense of community she needed without realizing it.
“That’s what I wanted to build here,” she said. “A sense of welcome, faith, community, gathering—the home feeling that I got when I was in St. Clare.”
The last word in the name is just as deliberate. A collective, she said, reflects how carefully each item was chosen and how she hopes to bring other people into the project. She is already working on that second goal. A local painter was scheduled to visit the shop this week to show Mrs. Fleming her work, which Mrs. Fleming hopes to carry.
Three of Mrs. Fleming’s four children attend the cathedral’s elementary school, Sacred Heart Cathedral School, and the fourth is in the preschool, which all four have attended since infancy. The couple’s connection to the cathedral parish runs through nearly every part of their family life.
Mrs. Fleming said the work has also deepened her own faith. Researching saints she had not thought about in years, she said, has been like relearning her Catholic upbringing, and she has passed those lessons on to her children and her friends.
Filling The Paraclete’s place, in her own way
The shop arrives in a community that has been missing a dedicated Catholic gift store since July 2024, when The Paraclete closed after 37 years in Knoxville. The closing initially looked like part of a national trend, as Catholic book and gift stores faced growing competition from online retailers.
Mrs. Fleming was a frequent Paraclete customer, and she said the store was the place she went when she needed a quick gift. When her nephew was confirmed, for example, it was easy to stop in and pick something up.
She does not describe Saint Clare Collective as a replacement, however.
“My goal was never to replicate The Paraclete,” she said. “I wanted to be Saint Clare Collective.”
The aim, she said, was to carry forward what was valuable about the older store while making it “modern, with my own twist on it,” and to meet what she believes her friends, family, the Sacred Heart community, and Knoxville’s wider Catholic community have always wanted.
Mrs. Fleming also believes the tide has turned against pure online shopping.
“I didn’t want to buy another generic item from a website, unsure of the exact color or material or the quality at all,” particularly for keepsakes meant to mark life’s most important moments, she said. A high-quality rosary given as a gift, she added, is something a person can feel and touch before buying.
What’s on the shelves
Inventory is broad, running from the devotional to the whimsical. Religious offerings include Bibles and devotional books, crosses and crucifixes, medals, pendants and rosaries, icons, statues, art and holy cards depicting Christ, Mary, and the saints as well as Nativities, Advent wreaths, and devotional candles. The shop also stocks gifts, keepsakes, and clothing for sacramental milestones such as baptism, first Holy Communion, and matrimony. Confirmation items are already on display, and Mrs. Fleming has Lent, Easter, St. Patrick’s Day, and the first Communion season in mind for the months ahead.

Saint Clare Collective offers a variety of jewelry pieces symbolizing the faith such as the Sacred Heart, a cross, angels, and more. (Photo Bee Goodman)
The general inventory is deliberately wider. It includes home décor, women’s clothing and jewelry, University of Tennessee and other sports-themed items, seasonal ornaments, mahjong sets and accessories, children’s toys, and handmade and small-batch pieces by local and out-of-town makers.
One section is all Mrs. Fleming’s own doing. The Lantern & Lily corner holds one-of-a-kind found objects and vintage pieces, thrifted from estate sales and secondhand finds across East Tennessee. Mrs. Fleming has long enjoyed hunting for such items and giving them what she calls a second home.
“Most of them I want to keep for myself,” she said, “but I have to put them back out for this store.”
The store is not exclusively Catholic, and Mrs. Fleming said that is intentional. The shop carries Christian, spiritual, and entirely secular merchandise.
“We are proud of both our faith-based offerings and universal products,” she said, “and we welcome people of all and any faiths and none whatsoever who may want to browse our diverse selection.”
The atmosphere feels far from a 9-to-5 corporate retailer. Each item is especially curated from Mrs. Fleming and her family and goes through the hand of a person who has dedicated the space to their Catholic faith.
Though regular hours have yet to be announced, those with questions can follow Saint Clare Collective on Facebook and Instagram at @SaintClareCollective. Mrs. Fleming also shares that if the open sign is hanging out front, then the doors will be open for business.
‘Welcome and warm and invited’
Mrs. Fleming says her goal for each customer is simple: “I want everyone to feel welcome and warm and invited,” she said.
Some stores, she said, feel stiff and cold, and shoppers want to hurry out. She hopes people will linger at Saint Clare Collective, whether they are shopping for themselves or choosing as a hostess, baptism, or holiday gift, and that they will find something they were not looking for.
“I think the store is less about what is in our inventory and more about why it was selected: to bring joy, comfort, peace, inspiration, and beauty to your home, your family, your life, and to those with whom you share these gifts,” Mrs. Fleming said.
Her sense that the project was meant to happen has only grown.
“I think the Holy Spirit is just like, ‘I know what you’re doing, so I’m going to work with you,’” she said.

